Blog
Why Most Difficult Conversation Training is Complete Rubbish (And What Actually Works)
Related Articles:
You know what really gets under my skin? Watching another middle manager stumble through a performance review like they're defusing a bomb. Eyes darting everywhere except at the employee, voice pitched higher than a teenager asking for the car keys, hands doing that weird corporate jazz-hands thing that's supposed to look confident but screams "help me."
I've been training people in difficult conversations for seventeen years now, and I reckon 73% of what passes for "communication skills training" these days is about as useful as a chocolate teapot. Most of it focuses on scripts and templates, as if human emotion operates like a bloody spreadsheet.
Here's what nobody wants to admit: difficult conversations aren't difficult because we don't know what to say. They're difficult because we're terrified of the consequences.
The Real Problem Nobody Talks About
The training industry has convinced everyone that there's a magic formula for handling tricky discussions. Follow these seven steps! Use this sandwich method! Mirror their body language!
Complete nonsense.
I once watched a CEO in Perth try to use the "compliment sandwich" method to tell someone their project was getting canned. Started with "You've got great attention to detail," moved to "We're shutting down your entire division," then finished with "Your PowerPoint slides are always well-formatted." The poor bloke looked like he'd been hit by a truck reversing into a brick wall.
The employee later told me it was the most insulting conversation of his career. Not because he lost his job – he saw that coming. But because his boss treated him like an idiot who needed to be managed rather than a human being who deserved straight talk.
What Actually Works (Spoiler: It's Simpler Than You Think)
Forget everything you've been taught about difficult conversations. The only thing that matters is this: respect and honesty.
That's it. Not revolutionary, is it? But here's why it works when fancy frameworks don't – people can smell authenticity from a mile away. They also know when you're following a script.
I've seen warehouse supervisors in Adelaide handle redundancy conversations better than Harvard MBAs because they understood one simple truth: the conversation isn't about you and your comfort level. It's about the other person and their need to understand what's happening.
The approach that actually works:
Be direct. Say what needs saying without dancing around it like you're performing Swan Lake.
Be present. Put your phone away. Close your laptop. Look at them when they're talking.
Be prepared for emotion. Humans have feelings. Shocking, I know.
Answer their questions honestly. If you don't know something, say so. If you can't tell them something, explain why.
The rest is just theatre.
Why Your Current Training is Failing
Most communication training fails because it tries to eliminate the human element from human interactions. It's like teaching someone to swim without letting them near water.
I remember working with a manufacturing company in Brisbane where they'd spent $50,000 on a communication consultant who taught their supervisors to use something called "non-violent communication." Sounds lovely, doesn't it?
Three months later, productivity was down, grievances were up, and half the floor supervisors were having nervous breakdowns because they couldn't figure out how to tell someone they were consistently late without hurting their feelings.
The problem wasn't the method – it was the mindset. They'd been taught that difficult conversations should be painless. But some conversations need to hurt a little bit. That discomfort is what motivates change.
The Australian Advantage (Yes, Really)
Here's something I learned working across different countries: Australians are actually brilliant at difficult conversations when we stop trying to be someone else.
We're naturally direct without being cruel. We can be serious without being stuffy. We understand that sometimes you need to call a spade a bloody shovel, and that's okay.
But somewhere along the way, corporate Australia decided we needed to sound more "professional." More American. More... soft.
Biggest mistake companies make: importing communication styles from other cultures without understanding our workplace context.
I watched a mining company in WA hire an American consultant who taught their site managers to start every difficult conversation with small talk about the weather. In 45-degree heat. While standing next to machinery that costs more than most people's houses.
The workers thought management had lost their minds.
What the Best Managers Actually Do
The managers who excel at difficult conversations share three characteristics:
They prepare for the outcome, not the conversation. They know what needs to happen next, regardless of how the discussion goes.
They stay curious instead of defensive. When someone gets upset, they ask questions instead of making statements.
They follow through. Always. Every time. Without exception.
I've worked with leaders who handle office politics brilliantly, and they all understand that consistency builds trust faster than any communication technique.
The best difficult conversation I ever witnessed happened in a Sydney accounting firm. The senior partner needed to tell a junior accountant that clients were complaining about his attitude.
No preamble. No sandwich method. Just: "Mike, we need to talk about your client interactions. Three clients have complained about your attitude this month. Tell me what's going on."
Mike broke down. Turns out his marriage was falling apart, he hadn't slept properly in weeks, and he was taking anxiety medication that was making him irritable.
Instead of a disciplinary conversation, it became a support conversation. Mike got help, kept his job, and five years later became one of their best client managers.
Would that have happened if his boss had followed a script? Not a chance.
The Uncomfortable Truth About Difficult Conversations
Here's what training companies won't tell you: some conversations will go badly no matter what you do.
Sometimes people get angry. Sometimes they cry. Sometimes they storm out. Sometimes they threaten to call Fair Work or their union or their lawyer or their mother.
And that's okay.
Your job isn't to manage their emotions – it's to deliver information clearly and treat them with respect while you do it.
I learned this the hard way during my early days as a trainer. Spent hours crafting the perfect approach for a restructure conversation, anticipated every possible reaction, prepared responses for every scenario.
The employee listened politely, said "I understand," shook my hand, and left quietly.
Two hours later, HR called. He'd cleaned out his desk, sent a company-wide email about management incompetence, and walked out. My perfect conversation meant nothing because I'd focused on the delivery instead of what happened after.
The Real Training People Need
If I could redesign difficult conversation training from scratch, here's what I'd include:
Scenario-based practice with real consequences. Not role-playing with colleagues who'll see you in the tea room later.
Emotional regulation techniques. Because you can't help someone else stay calm if you're falling apart.
Legal and policy knowledge. Understanding what you can and can't say, promise, or agree to.
Follow-up planning. What happens after the conversation ends?
Cultural awareness. How different backgrounds affect communication preferences.
But most importantly: permission to be human.
The obsession with professionalism has sucked the humanity out of workplace interactions. We've created robots in suits who speak in corporate jargon and wonder why nobody trusts them.
Getting It Right
The best difficult conversation training I ever delivered was to a group of retail managers in Melbourne. Instead of teaching techniques, I made them practice being themselves while delivering bad news.
No scripts. No frameworks. Just honesty, respect, and clear communication.
Their customer complaint levels dropped by 40% in six months. Not because they learned better techniques, but because customers started trusting them again.
Bottom line: difficult conversations aren't a skill you learn – they're a relationship you build. With practice, honesty, and a bit of backbone.
The training industry has overcomplicated something that humans have been doing since we lived in caves. Sometimes you need to tell someone something they don't want to hear. Do it with respect, do it clearly, and do it completely.
Everything else is just expensive noise.
Our Favorite Training Resources: